Lawyers in My AreaFind a lawyer in your area

Costs & choices

How to request a second legal opinion

Request a second legal opinion with a clear question, existing advice and relevant documents. Compare the review scope and clarify your current representation.

By Lawyers in My Area · General preparation guidance

Published · Updated

01

The legal question for independent review

A second opinion works best when you can name the uncertainty. You may want to understand an assumption, compare an option or clarify a document. Write down that question and why it matters to your next decision. Distinguish dissatisfaction with communication from disagreement with a legal conclusion. Both deserve attention, but they may call for different conversations and a different amount of document review.

02

Your existing lawyer and current engagement

Tell the new office whether another lawyer is currently acting and what work is underway. Identify any immediate date or event and ask what initial checks are needed. Do not assume the second office can accept the enquiry simply because it offers the same broad service. Clarify whether you are requesting advice only or considering a change of representation; a conversation does not automatically transfer responsibility.

03

Documents and advice to provide

Ask which documents the second adviser needs, including the earlier advice if appropriate. Explain the facts and materials on which it was based, and identify anything that has changed since then. A difference in conclusions can reflect a difference in information rather than a simple right-or-wrong choice. Avoid sending only the sentence you disagree with while omitting the qualifications that accompanied it.

04

Comparing the reasoning and scope of legal opinions

Ask the second lawyer to explain the assumptions, limits and further information needed. Confirm the fee for reviewing the file and whether a written opinion is included. Keep responsibility for current tasks explicit while you consider the advice. If you decide to change lawyers, discuss transfer arrangements separately. A second opinion is useful when it clarifies a decision; it does not promise a more favourable answer or outcome.

05

Second opinions versus changing lawyers

A second opinion can be a limited review while an existing adviser continues the matter. If you later want to change representation, ask both offices about the transition, the current file and responsibility for active work. Keep communications clear about what has actually been agreed. Do not assume that sending documents to a new office means it has accepted the engagement or taken responsibility for an upcoming step. Ask for written confirmation of the review’s scope so you can distinguish independent advice from an agreed transfer of the matter.

06

Define the question that needs another assessment

A second opinion is most useful when it addresses a specific uncertainty. Examples include whether an existing explanation considered a particular document, how two proposed options differ, or whether the scope of work matches the decision you face. Write down the question and the advice you have already received without editing it to support your preferred answer. If the concern is communication, timing or cost rather than the substance of the advice, say so. Those concerns may require a different conversation. A request to confirm that the first lawyer is wrong is less useful than a request to explain the reasoning and assumptions behind the available options.

07

Supply the context that makes the opinions comparable

Identify the documents and facts available to the first adviser, any material received later and the stage the matter has reached. If a later opinion relies on new information, the difference may reflect changed facts rather than a disagreement about the same question. Provide the written advice where appropriate and ask how it should be shared securely. Explain whether proceedings, negotiations or a transaction are continuing. A second adviser needs to know if an imminent decision limits the available time for review. Do not assume that commissioning another opinion transfers responsibility for current work or tells your existing lawyer to stop.

08

Use a reasoning comparison instead of a vote

For each opinion, record the question answered, the factual assumptions, the options discussed, the risks explained and the work outside scope. Where the conclusions differ, ask which assumption or issue accounts for the difference. Two advisers may use different levels of caution or address different stages. A conclusion you prefer is not automatically the more reliable one, and counting opinions does not resolve a legal question. The useful result is a clearer understanding of why the advice differs and what further information would reduce uncertainty. Keep the comparison private and factual rather than turning it into an accusation against either adviser.

09

Worked example: review of advice before a business decision

A company receives advice on a contract clause but wants another assessment before committing to a significant change in operations. The second engagement can be scoped to the clause, the operational assumptions and the first advice, without commissioning a complete review of unrelated documents. Ask what the second adviser will deliver and what remains outside scope. After receiving it, decide who will handle any follow-up drafting or negotiations and confirm that separately. If you choose to change advisers entirely, address the transfer, outstanding tasks and acceptance of responsibility rather than assuming the second-opinion appointment completed that transition.

Define the question the second opinion must answer

Complete this in private notes. Keep facts, missing information and questions separate. The aim is a usable record for your next decision, not a legal conclusion.

Existing advice
Date, author, scope and the facts or documents it considered.
Uncertainty
Identify the reasoning, assumption or option you want explained.
Changed information
List new facts or documents received since the first advice.
Deliverable
Clarify whether you want a written review, conference or assessment of a defined alternative.

Worked example

A second lawyer appears to disagree, but was given a later contract version and no copy of the first advice. Before treating this as conflicting expertise, compare the question, documents and assumptions. The exercise helps identify whether the opinions address the same problem. Keep the current lawyer’s responsibilities and any urgent next step clear while seeking the review.

You can print this page or copy the prompts into private notes. No case information is collected here.

Frequently asked questions

Does seeking a second opinion end my current engagement?

Do not assume that it does. Clarify the existing and proposed arrangements directly, including who remains responsible for current work.

Does seeking another opinion end my existing engagement?

Do not assume so. Review the current arrangement and discuss who remains responsible for ongoing tasks. The new adviser should know that another firm is involved. Any change of representation, file transfer or instruction to stop work needs to be handled explicitly.

Should I hide the first opinion so the second lawyer is independent?

Ask how the new adviser wants to scope the review. Withholding relevant advice or documents can remove important context. Explain your concern about an independent assessment, identify the material available and agree the review method rather than selectively presenting the facts.

Official resources and further reading

Official background: lsbc.vic.gov.au ↗

This guide helps you prepare an enquiry. It does not assess your rights, calculate deadlines or replace advice about your circumstances.